Barry Playground: price concept options separately from seawall assumptions
Separate two Barry Playground concepts from the existing seawall investigation before building a conceptual estimate.
Author
Ido Gedanken, CEOPublished

Bring a current or completed project and see how Piper saves review time, surfaces scope gaps, and applies your company's knowledge.
Book a demo- Type
- Guide
- Read
- 2 min
- Published
On this page
For a conceptual estimate at Charlestown's Barry Playground, keep the two community concepts in separate options and the seawall investigation in its own decision gate. A berm or elevated boardwalk shown in one concept is not a selected scope, and visible erosion is not a seawall replacement design.
The City project page says the design process will evaluate the existing seawall. It identifies Weston & Sampson as consultant, with contractor and completion date to be determined. The November 18, 2025 community presentation is a dated options discussion, not an issued construction set. Its tentative 2027 construction and 2028 opening dates were forecasts at that time, not current commitments.
Option and investigation register
| Record | Presentation evidence | Estimator's next decision |
|---|---|---|
| Common basis | Softball and open lawn retained in both concepts | Establish the common work and exclusions from a current design basis |
| Concept 1 | Overlook, integrated seating and stairs, trike track | Price only as an identified option after receiving scope and dimensions |
| Concept 2 | Landscape berm, terraced seating and elevated boardwalk | Keep separate from Concept 1 and request design and ground assumptions |
| Existing seawall | Presentation notes erosion behind it; City says condition will be evaluated | Obtain condition assessment and selected response before carrying repair or replacement |
The options also illustrate common amenities. Do not add both alternative waterfront treatments to a base estimate simply because both appear in the presentation. Nor should the apparent geometry of a community rendering be used as takeoff. Request a current preferred concept, survey, elevations, materials and limits, then preserve the source and revision for each quantity.
Keep seawall risk visible without inventing a repair
An estimate can separately identify an unresolved seawall condition and the work dependent on it. Ask for the assessment's extent, what was actually inspected, its findings and the designer's selected response. Then ask whether proposed park grading, waterfront access or the boardwalk option changes the investigation or construction boundary. Until an issued solution exists, label any allowance and its assumptions rather than describing replacement as awarded.
The City's presentation also documents a cracked entry and a disconnected walking loop. These observations help frame design questions, but do not establish the limits or method of repair. The useful next step is a scoped comparison: common work, each option's incremental work, and the seawall decision shown separately. That makes it possible to revise one without quietly changing the others.
Turn a chosen option into packages
Once a design is issued, reconcile site work, waterfront work, access, finishes and restoration at the actual boundaries. Check the issued revision before comparing prices, and use the scope generation guide to preserve the source for each package decision.
Related reading
Construction scope generation: a practical guide for GCs
How general contractors turn drawings, specifications, addenda, and company standards into trade scopes a subcontractor can price, an estimator can trace, and a senior reviewer can challenge.

Construction addenda management for GC estimators
Addenda are official bid-document revisions. Log them, distribute them, retakeoff the deltas, and require subcontractor acknowledgments so your estimate and every bid reflect the final scope.

Piper removes manual review from the critical path and brings project data, company knowledge, and expert checks into every preconstruction decision and workflow
See Piper on your project
Bring a current or completed project and see how Piper saves review time, surfaces scope gaps, and applies your company's knowledge.