Construction unit-price bids: review quantities and included work before carrying

Test a unit-price bid against quantity changes, measurement rules and mobilization assumptions. Separate the quoted rate from the cost of changed quantities.

Guide3 min read

Published

Tower crane against an overcast sky

Bring a current or completed project and see how Piper saves review time, surfaces scope gaps, and applies your company's knowledge.

Book a demo
On this page
  1. Start with the pay item and measurement rule
  2. Find fixed costs and missing work
  3. Test a quantity range before carrying
  4. Use a pay-item review register
  5. Compare rate scope against the project

A unit-price bid gives a rate for a defined unit of work. Before a commercial GC estimator carries the extension, establish the quantity basis, what the rate buys and how quantity changes affect both the prime and subcontract. A low rate on the bid form can still leave a costly gap if mobilization, disposal or the measurement basis sits elsewhere.

An extension is a comparison at an assumed quantity, not a prediction of the final payment. The actual agreement controls measurement, payment, adjustments and responsibility for quantity changes. A unit-price item can coexist with lump-sum items on the same project.

Start with the pay item and measurement rule

For each item, record the description, unit, bid-form quantity, rate and extension, together with the document and revision establishing the measurement rule. FHWA's highway cost-index methodology describes pay-item data in terms of price, unit and quantity. Its highway context is an illustration, not a payment rule for a building contract.

Ask whether quantities are measured in place, by truck ticket, by weight or by another defined method. Check treatment of waste, over-excavation, unsuitable material, minimum quantities and changes in work. Do not assume a yard on a subcontractor's quote means the same thing as a yard on the owner's schedule. Separate takeoff from estimating so the measured or assumed quantity remains visible beside the pricing judgment.

Find fixed costs and missing work

Read the unit-rate inclusions and exclusions alongside the specifications, bid form and proposal. Is mobilization a separate lump sum? Does the rate include loading, hauling, disposal fees, testing, equipment standby, supervision and markup? A rate that embeds a fixed mobilization cost may behave differently from a rate with mobilization separately priced when quantities change. A minimum charge or a contractual re-pricing provision may also change the calculation.

Keep the owner-facing pay item separate from the subcontractor's rate. A GC may be paid for one unit while buying another scope or unit; the agreement, measurement and actual production determine the exposure. Confirm the interface instead of presuming the two rates automatically offset.

Test a quantity range before carrying

Illustrative example: a commercial excavation package has an owner bid quantity of 1,000 cubic yards. Assume the prime pays $80 per measured cubic yard, the subcontract is $60 per the same measured yard, and mobilization is a separate $10,000 subcontract lump sum. Assume no other costs, minimums or adjustments. These simplified figures are not a project price or forecast.

ScenarioQuantityPrime revenueSubcontract cost including mobilizationDifference before other GC costs
Low600 CY$48,000$46,000$2,000
Bid basis1,000 CY$80,000$70,000$10,000
High1,400 CY$112,000$94,000$18,000

The difference is not profit: it excludes all other GC costs, risk and taxes. The example shows how the fixed $10,000 consumes more of the spread at lower quantities. If measurement units, actual work, rates, minimums or contractual adjustments differ, recalculate rather than applying this pattern. The low and high cases are sensitivity tests, not bounds on actual quantity.

Use a pay-item review register

FieldDecision to record
Item and sourceBid-form line and measurement clause with revision
Quantity and unitOwner quantity and independent basis with unit conversion
Rate and inclusionsOriginal offer and what labor material equipment and disposal cover
Fixed or minimum costsSeparate mobilization standby minimum and payment trigger
Low and high caseQuantity assumptions extension and permitted rate adjustments
Open issue and carryClarification owner deadline adjustment and unresolved exposure

Level each proposal at the same quantity and add excluded work only once. Preserve the original offer, the normalized comparison and the final carry separately. Request written clarification where a rate is silent, then reconcile the proposed subcontract terms with the prime's measurement and adjustment provisions. Escalate material mismatches before bid submission or award.

Compare rate scope against the project

Piper Bid Leveling compares subcontractor proposals against intended scope with source-linked findings. The estimator still tests quantities, evaluates the commercial terms and chooses the carry.

ShareLinkedInX

Related reading

Guide7 min

How to set a carry number you can defend

The method for getting from a submitted subcontractor bid to the number that actually goes in the estimate, including evaluated cost, expected-value risk pricing, and the duplicate-contingency trap.

Construction scaffolding interior

Piper removes manual review from the critical path and brings project data, company knowledge, and expert checks into every preconstruction decision and workflow

See Piper on your project

Bring a current or completed project and see how Piper saves review time, surfaces scope gaps, and applies your company's knowledge.