Port roof packages: distinguish Shed 5 reroofing from skylight closure

Price the Port of Albany’s archived Shed 5 roof work and Mohawk skylight closures on separate quantities, materials, and trade interfaces.

Guide4 min read

Published

Construction scaffolding interior

Bring a current or completed project and see how Piper saves review time, surfaces scope gaps, and applies your company's knowledge.

Book a demo
On this page
  1. Retain, remove and install: two different estimates
  2. Carry the timber estimate without calling it a measured repair
  3. Assign the handoffs before comparing prices
  4. What to verify before carrying a current price

For a chief estimator comparing these Port of Albany packages, the decisive distinction is the unit of work. Shed 5 is a roof-system installation over a retained built-up roof, with selective timber replacement and substantial perimeter work. Mohawk is a closure and watertight tie-in at 15 skylights. Carrying either as a generic roof replacement can put the wrong demolition, quantities and trades in the estimate.

This guide compares archived issued scopes; it does not establish current availability or independently verify physical completion. The combined Mohawk PDF contains an award-designated bid row; its listed completion date is not an observed completion receipt. The Albany Port District Commission (APDC) issued Shed 5 RFP 2025-02 on April 10, 2025, and Mohawk RFP 2025-03 on May 12, 2025. Check the current owner record, addenda and site conditions before using either scope on a live project.

Retain, remove and install: two different estimates

The matrix summarizes the owner’s historical scope. The proposed handoffs are estimating analysis, not an assertion that the RFP assigned separate subcontracts.

ItemShed 5 roof repair and replacementMohawk skylight closure
Existing roofingRetain built-up roof; remove obstructing flashingTie closure membrane into existing roof; full reroof is not described
DemolitionRemove stone ballast, specified edge drainage and deteriorated chimneyRemove skylight glass, mullion covers and ridge caps at 15 openings
Deck or openingReplace deteriorated wood decking as needed, matching existing dimensions and speciesCover openings with 3/4-inch pressure-treated plywood attached to mullions
New weatheringInstall specified substrate and new TPO roof systemAdd insulation board, fabricated aluminum caps and EPDM closure tied watertight to existing roof
Edge and interfacesRepoint north and south parapets and seal coping; replace specified drainage and address roof appurtenancesPrice each opening and its membrane tie-in; verify any other roof penetrations separately

The Shed 5 RFP describes a roughly 38,232-square-foot roof and calls for ballast removal while the built-up roof remains. It specifies a new substrate and membrane, plus gutter, downspout and parapet work. Its scope also describes vent-fan repairs and flashing, and removal of a deteriorated chimney by a qualified mason. These are linked activities even if the roofer, sheet-metal contractor and mason submit separate prices. See the Shed 5 scope and engineering material, especially the project narrative and overall scope.

The Mohawk RFP identifies a paper-storage warehouse at 108 Smith Boulevard. It describes 15 skylights, each nominally 10 by 30 feet, and specifies removal of glass and covers, plywood over the openings, aluminum ridge and corners, insulation board and EPDM tied into the existing roof. The owner also describes the larger existing roof, but the specified objective is skylight closure, not a complete Mohawk reroof. Do not transfer Shed 5's roof area or decking allowance to Mohawk. Source: Mohawk RFP, purpose and scope.

Carry the timber estimate without calling it a measured repair

The Shed 5 documents estimate that about 5% of the roof area, or 1,912 square feet of shiplap, may need replacement. They say the actual deterioration will be established once roofing work begins and direct bidders to verify dimensions, quantities and conditions in the field. That is a pricing basis, not an observed final replacement quantity. Source: Shed 5 RFP, project narrative and scope.

For an estimate built from this historic basis, list the 1,912 square feet separately from the roof-system area. Identify material, removal, replacement labor and access in the carry, and request a unit price and measurement method for quantity variation if the contract permits. Confirm who approves exposed deterioration, records dimensions before cover-up, and authorizes extra work. Do not assume the historical estimate itself establishes a contractual allowance or change-order entitlement.

For Mohawk, start instead with 15 individual closures. The nominal opening dimensions give 4,500 square feet of plan opening area as a screening calculation, not a material order: caps, slopes, laps, waste, attachment and actual field dimensions affect quantities. Ask whether each proposal includes all 15 openings and a complete watertight tie-in, then reconcile exclusions and unit assumptions. The two jobs have different quantity drivers even though both involve roofing crews.

Assign the handoffs before comparing prices

InterfaceProposed estimate owner and evidence to obtainDecision to close
Shed 5 timberRoofer or carpentry bidder identifies included quantity and unit rate; superintendent records exposed conditionWho approves replacement and how is it measured before concealment?
Shed 5 parapets and chimneyMason prices repointing, coping sealing and chimney removal; roofer identifies flashing and tie-in at adjacent workWho sequences the trades and accepts the watertight transition?
Shed 5 fans and drainageRoofing and sheet-metal bids identify fan housing repair, flashing, gutters and downspoutsAre removal, replacement, disposal and final connections all carried once?
Mohawk openingsRoofing bidder identifies glass removal, plywood, caps, insulation, EPDM and existing-roof tie-in for each openingWho owns glass handling, support verification and finished watertightness?
Both occupied storage roofsGC and roofing bidder state weather protection, work zones and daily close-up assumptionsWho protects stored material and pays for temporary protection or interruption?

The last row is a recommended pricing handoff, not a claim that the historic documents allocate all cargo-protection duties to a particular trade. Shed 5 is described as storage for dry goods, and Mohawk as paper storage. Before pricing a comparable live job, agree with the owner on what remains inside, access windows, temporary covers, leak response and the area that can be opened and made weather-tight each day. A low roof bid that assumes an empty building is not directly comparable with a bid carrying protection over inventory.

The Shed 5 appendix includes a limited asbestos survey. Its scope and limitations matter: it is not an abatement specification or design, and concealed materials may not have been identified. Have the appropriate qualified parties review the actual report, affected materials and current project documents, then establish any required further investigation, design, pricing and sequencing before disturbing material. The survey title alone does not establish the condition of every roof component. Source: Shed 5 RFP, survey appendix.

What to verify before carrying a current price

Obtain the current scope, drawings, addenda and project status from the owner. Confirm site dimensions and access, the roof assembly and condition, operating constraints, product compatibility and warranty terms. Resolve the timber measurement and authorization procedure on a Shed 5-like job; on a Mohawk-like job verify each opening, support condition, glass handling and the extent of each tie-in. Assign any other penetrations only after identifying them in the applicable documents and site inspection.

Use the public-project stage guide to place the evidence at the right project stage, then check estimate scope coverage for work omitted by every bidder. The useful comparison is not simply the lowest roof price: it is the price after each bidder has acknowledged the same work, protection assumptions and unresolved quantities.

ShareLinkedInX

Related reading

Piper removes manual review from the critical path and brings project data, company knowledge, and expert checks into every preconstruction decision and workflow

See Piper on your project

Bring a current or completed project and see how Piper saves review time, surfaces scope gaps, and applies your company's knowledge.