Preconstruction agreements: reconcile paid services, authority and the next commitment

Review the services, compensation and decision authority in a preconstruction agreement before an estimate request becomes an unpriced commitment.

Guide3 min read

Published

Tower crane above steel reinforcement

Bring a current or completed project and see how Piper saves review time, surfaces scope gaps, and applies your company's knowledge.

Book a demo
On this page
  1. Find the boundaries in the actual agreement
  2. Build an agreement review register
  3. Separate six decisions that can look like approval
  4. Work through a third estimate request

Before a GC or CM accepts paid preconstruction work, reconcile the promised outputs with the time, compensation and authority needed to produce them. An agreement to prepare an estimate is incomplete for planning purposes if the team cannot identify its document baseline, revision allowance, recipient and the person who can resolve a request outside that baseline.

Start with the proposed agreement and all incorporated exhibits, amendments and schedules. The register below is a review aid, not a contract form or a determination of rights. Have counsel and authorized signatories settle the terms. Use it to make the questions they need to answer traceable.

Find the boundaries in the actual agreement

For a CM-at-risk assignment, distinguish the preconstruction engagement from the later construction commitment. The AIA A133-2019 public instructions provide one bounded example: they address preconstruction services and compensation separately from construction compensation, and describe an owner who may accept, reject or negotiate a GMP proposal. They are instructions for a particular form, not the executed agreement or a universal fee rule.

Even in that example, do not treat GMP acceptance as the only conceivable start route. The AIA CMc FAQ describes commencement through a GMP amendment or a written agreement before GMP acceptance. Read the actual documents to determine what, if anything, has been authorized. A paid preconstruction engagement alone should not be treated as a construction award.

Build an agreement review register

The following is an illustrative register for a commercial CM estimating assignment. Replace every assumption with the applicable section, exhibit and named project role before relying on it. The rightmost question is an open decision, not a proposed contract clause.

Review itemExample baseline to reconcileEvidence and decision to obtain
Service and outputTwo estimates at identified design milestones, with documented assumptions and exclusionsIdentify the scope exhibit, versions of drawings and specifications, and whether trade pricing is included
Revisions and durationOne reconciliation of each estimate during the stated service periodFind the revision allowance and end date; ask who decides whether a later redesign is within scope
Staffing and dependenciesEstimating lead and trade input depend on timely design and owner informationIdentify named resources or effort assumptions, information providers, expected dates and the response to missing inputs
Receipt and acceptanceDeliver estimate to the owner's designated representativeRecord the recipient, required format, acceptance criteria and evidence; distinguish receipt from acceptance
Fee and billingFee and invoice milestones identified in the agreementRecord billing basis, deliverable or time support, invoice reviewer and the person authorized to approve payment
ReimbursablesTravel or specialist input only if the agreement provides for itIdentify eligible expenses, required advance approval, approver and supporting records
Extension and additional workA later estimate or delayed input may exceed the described period or allowanceIdentify the trigger and who can agree to scope, fee and schedule changes; leave unresolved items open
Early work and next commitmentPricing an early equipment package is distinct from placing an orderIdentify procurement authority, spending limit, required written authorization and separate construction start or commitment documents

The estimate itself needs a reliable decision baseline. Define the deliverables supporting the next decision alongside this commercial review: an acceptance rule cannot compensate for an unidentified drawing set or an unclear exclusion.

Separate six decisions that can look like approval

An owner's review of information may request clarification without accepting the deliverable. Acknowledging receipt may establish delivery without resolving whether the submission meets the agreement. Acceptance, if defined in the documents, is a separate decision from approving an invoice. Likewise, permission to investigate a long-lead item is not necessarily authority to issue a purchase order, and an early procurement authorization is not necessarily a notice to begin all construction or a final construction commitment.

For each step, record the document and version, decision sought, authorized role, required form of record and any conditions or dollar limits. If the agreement is silent or documents conflict, mark the authority unresolved and route the question to counsel and the authorized signatories. Do not infer authority from a meeting invitation or an email acknowledgment.

Work through a third estimate request

Suppose the agreement describes two estimates during a six-month service period, with one reconciliation of each. After that period, the owner asks for a third estimate using a substantially revised mechanical design. This is a hypothetical review, not a conclusion that extra compensation is automatically owed.

The preconstruction lead should log the dated request and revised design set, compare them with the service and revision language, and identify the staffing and trade-pricing time needed. Ask the authorized parties to resolve whether the request falls within the agreed scope, what compensation and reimbursables apply, and whether the schedule or service period changes. Record the agreed direction and its authority before treating the revised forecast as a committed deliverable. If the owner also asks to reserve equipment, separately identify whether a purchase commitment is authorized and on what terms.

The handoff is ready when the team can point to the governing records for the current service, the next decision and any open commercial issue. If a decision remains open, assign a person and a date for resolution rather than silently carrying the request in the fee.

ShareLinkedInX

Related reading

Piper removes manual review from the critical path and brings project data, company knowledge, and expert checks into every preconstruction decision and workflow

See Piper on your project

Bring a current or completed project and see how Piper saves review time, surfaces scope gaps, and applies your company's knowledge.